Clausewitz and Jomini: Drawing the Line between Art and Science
Clausewitz and Jomini: Drawing the Line between Art and Science In the West, two military philosophers have had much influence on the military arts and, will remain influential for time to come. But both are influential for different reasons. And many immediately see their similarities but their differences, however, are very nuanced. Jomini has had many readers, and simultaneously, critics as well. Especially when compared against Clausewitz. And “ most of what Jomini had to contribute that was of real value—which was a great deal—has long since been absorbed into the way we write practical doctrine.” [1] Jomini thought warfare as the ultimate drama to be conducted between geniuses. And Jomini surely saw (or preferred) combat between ‘chivalrous’ hosts. “As a soldier, preferring loyal and chivalrous warfare to organized assassination.” [2] Both men were ‘of their time’ however, Clausewitz, being heavily influenced by such ‘Continentalist’ philosophers such as Immanue...
Comments
Post a Comment