“Conventional Commanders in an Unconventional War: The U.S. Army in Vietnam 1965-1973” Chapter Layout and Outline

-

 “Conventional Commanders in an Unconventional War: The U.S. Army in Vietnam 1965-1973”



Chapter Descriptions and Layout

Introduction

·         The study examines U.S. Army maneuver commanders in the Vietnam War from 1965-1973. It highlights how these commanders shaped tactics and operations and influenced MACV strategy. 

     ·         Main Points:

o   The research emphasizes the extensive combat experience of these commanders, many of whom served in WWII and Korea.

o   It also addresses how they interpreted and implemented MACV strategy and the distinct leadership challenges they faced.

o   The study uses primary sources like Combat After-Action Reports and Lessons Learned to analyze their influence on combat operations, tactics, and strategy.   

o   It notes the complexities of the Vietnam War, including counterinsurgency, pacification, and coordination with ARVN forces.   

o   The author argues that understanding the role of these commanders is crucial to grasping the U.S. Army's strategy and the challenges faced in the conflict.   

 

Chapter 1: Military Assistance Command Vietnam and the Strategy

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter discusses the historical context of the U.S. Army's involvement in South Vietnam, starting from the aftermath of the French defeat in 1954 and the establishment of the Military Assistance and Advisory Group (MAAG). It explores the influence of the Korean War, the evolution of U.S. military strategy, and the challenges faced by MACV in the early stages of the conflict.

  • Main Points:
    • The legacy of the Korean War and the French defeat in Indochina significantly shaped U.S. involvement in Vietnam.
    • The U.S. Army underwent significant changes in force structure, technology, and doctrine in the post-Korean War era.
    • The establishment of MACV and the development of U.S. strategy in Vietnam were influenced by Cold War politics and the desire to contain communism.
    • Early strategies focused on supporting the South Vietnamese government and preventing communist expansion, evolving from conventional defense planning to counterinsurgency efforts.
    • General Westmoreland's leadership and the challenges faced by MACV in coordinating military and political efforts are highlighted.

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is historical and analytical, providing context and background to the U.S. Army’s involvement in Vietnam and the strategic challenges that shaped the role of maneuver commanders.

 

Chapter 2: The Key U.S. Army Maneuver Commanders

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter delves into the characteristics, training, and challenges faced by U.S. Army maneuver commanders in Vietnam. It discusses their extensive combat experience, the influence of doctrine and training, and the complexities of leading in an unconventional war.

  • Main Points:
    • Maneuver commanders were highly experienced, with many having served in WWII and Korea.
    • They operated within a complex environment, balancing conventional warfare with counterinsurgency and pacification efforts.
    • The role of the battalion commander as a key operational leader is emphasized, along with the challenges of intelligence gathering and unconventional warfare.  
    • Commanders had to adapt to the unique conditions of Vietnam, often employing innovative tactics and demonstrating initiative.
    • The chapter also explores the challenges of maintaining morale, troop readiness, and effective leadership amidst the difficulties of the war.

  • Narrative Style: The chapter combines historical exposition with an analysis of the leadership challenges and tactical considerations relevant to maneuver commanders in the Vietnam War. It includes specific examples and insights into the complexities of their role.

 

Chapter 3: 1965 The Build Up

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter describes the buildup of U.S. forces in South Vietnam in 1965, the strategic context, and the initial challenges faced by maneuver commanders. It details General Westmoreland's operational plans, the expansion of pacification programs, and the early combat experiences that shaped the understanding of the conflict.

 Main Points:

    • The chapter focuses on the initial deployment of U.S. forces and the implementation of General Westmoreland's three-phased approach.  
    • It addresses the complexities of pacification, security, and combat operations, and the challenges faced by commanders in coordinating these efforts.
    • The chapter also discusses the impact of the buildup on both U.S. troops and the ARVN, as well as the early lessons learned in adapting to the unique environment and enemy tactics in Vietnam.  

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is detailed and descriptive, providing a vivid account of the buildup phase, the operational concepts, and the initial challenges encountered by U.S. forces and their commanders.

 

Chapter 4: 1966-1967 “Slicks, Humping, and Victor Charlie”

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter examines the evolving nature of combat operations in 1966-1967, focusing on the increasing use of air mobility, the challenges of jungle warfare, and the adaptation of tactics to counter the Viet Cong.

  • Main Points:
    • The growing reliance on helicopters for troop movement and combat assaults is a key theme, along with the development of new tactics and techniques to maximize the effectiveness of air mobility.  
    • The chapter also discusses the difficulties of fighting in dense jungle terrain, the heavy physical demands on soldiers ("humping"), and the ongoing struggle to locate and engage the elusive enemy ("Victor Charlie").  
    • Tactical innovations, the impact of technology, and the constant adaptation of both U.S. forces and the Viet Cong are explored in detail.  

  • Narrative Style: The narrative combines action-oriented descriptions of combat with analysis of tactical developments and the challenges of command in a demanding environment. 

 

Chapter 5: Tet 1968 “Crack the Sky, Shake the Earth”

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter provides an in-depth account of the Tet Offensive, its impact on U.S. forces and strategy, and the experiences of maneuver commanders during this critical period of the war.

  • Main Points:
    • The chapter details the scale and intensity of the Tet Offensive, the widespread attacks across South Vietnam, and the initial surprise and challenges faced by U.S. forces.
    • It also examines the tactical and strategic implications of the offensive, the shift in public opinion in the United States, and the evolving strategies and priorities of both sides.  
    • The experiences of maneuver commanders on the ground, their leadership in the face of intense combat, and the lessons learned from the Tet Offensive are central themes.

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is dramatic and intense, capturing the chaos and urgency of the Tet Offensive, while also providing analysis of its broader significance and consequences.

 

Chapter 6: 1968-1969 The Toughest Years

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter analyzes the period following the Tet Offensive, characterized by continued combat, evolving U.S. strategy, and increasing challenges for maneuver commanders.

  • Main Points:
    • The chapter discusses the ongoing combat operations, the changing nature of the conflict, and the increasing focus on pacification and Vietnamization.  
    • Challenges such as troop morale, discipline, and the impact of domestic issues in the United States on the war effort are also explored.  
    • The chapter highlights the adaptation of maneuver commanders to these evolving circumstances and the continued demands placed on their leadership.  

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is analytical and reflective, examining the complexities of the post-Tet period and the challenges faced by U.S. forces and their commanders.

 

Chapter 7: 1970-1973 The Parrot’s Beak, Fishook, and Disengagement

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter details the final years of U.S. involvement in Vietnam, including operations in Cambodia, the gradual withdrawal of American forces, and the challenges of Vietnamization.

  • Main Points:
    • The chapter covers the controversial incursions into Cambodia (Parrot’s Beak, Fishook), the continuing combat operations, and the increasing focus on transitioning the war effort to the South Vietnamese.  
    • The challenges of maintaining morale and effectiveness during the withdrawal, the difficulties faced by ARVN forces, and the legacy of U.S. involvement in Vietnam are discussed.  
    • The role of maneuver commanders in overseeing the withdrawal, supporting ARVN, and adapting to the changing political and military landscape is a central focus.  

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is reflective and analytical, examining the complexities of the disengagement process and the lasting impact of the war.

 

Chapter 8: Introspection: The Officer Corps and Vietnam

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter delves into an introspective examination of the U.S. Army officer corps during the Vietnam War, analyzing the challenges, shortcomings, and lessons learned.

  • Main Points:
    • The chapter critically assesses the performance of the officer corps, addressing issues such as leadership, training, adaptation to unconventional warfare, and the impact of the war on the institution.
    • It also explores the professional development of officers, the influence of doctrine, and the need for institutional reform in the wake of the Vietnam experience.
    • The chapter emphasizes the importance of learning from past mistakes and adapting for future conflicts.

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is introspective and analytical, providing a critical examination of the U.S. Army and its officer corps during the Vietnam War.

 

Chapter 9: Conclusion and Findings

  • Chapter Summary: This chapter presents the study’s concluding analysis and key findings, summarizing the role and influence of maneuver commanders in the Vietnam War.

  • Main Points:
    • The chapter reiterates the central role of maneuver commanders in shaping tactical operations, influencing strategy, and adapting to the unique challenges of the conflict.
    • It highlights their experience, adaptability, and the impact of their decisions on the course of the war.  
    • The chapter also reflects on the broader implications of the study for understanding military leadership, strategy, and the conduct of unconventional warfare.

  • Narrative Style: The narrative is concise and summative, presenting the study’s key findings and their significance.

 

 Bibliography and Appendices

Summary: This chapter provides a comprehensive list of sources used in the research.

  • Main Points:
    • The bibliography includes a wide range of primary and secondary sources, demonstrating the depth and breadth of research that informed the study.
    • Commanders Database provided.
    • Data and Findings provided.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

“U.S. MARINE CORPS PRE-WAR TRAINING AND THE BATTLE OF BELLEAU WOOD: 1917-1918”

-
Image
I : Introduction                     The fighting in Belleau Wood, France, in  June, 1918 saw the command of the U.S. Marine 6th Machine Gun Battalion change hands four times in 11 days. Such was the nature of the vicious fight between the 4th Marine Brigade of the 2nd Infantry Division (U.S. Army) and the Germans pushing towards Paris. By all accounts, this first real test of the U.S Marines in the First World War, was a bloodletting that should have ended in a rout as the experienced and veteran German machine gunners tore into the inexperienced U.S. Marines. Rather than collapse, the 4th Marine Brigade withstood the German assaults and not only held firm, but triumphed. The U.S. Marine Corps 5th and 6th Marine Regiments in 1918 fought against the veteran and very experienced German infantry. This study seeks to identify how ad hoc Marine Corps infantry battalions and the newly formed 4...
Read more

Generals Lee, Sherman, And Grant: The Tactical vs the Strategic

-
Image
  Generals Lee, Sherman, And Grant: The Tactical vs the Strategic General Tecumseh Sherman has been memorialized for his “March to the Sea,” the carnage wrought upon Georgia from November to December of 1864. This campaign was the culmination of his own unique strategy, developed as a subordinate of General Grant, and as a student of his own successes and failings during the three previous years of campaigning against the Confederacy. Sherman had seen Grants magnificence in the Vicksburg campaign in 1863. Grant had all but abandoned his logistics columns and supply lines after they were destroyed by Confederate Cavalry. Undeterred, Grant continued. Sherman modeled this concept during his own “Meridian” Campaign in Mississippi. Sherman is more remembered for his Armies ‘March to the Sea’, burning and wrecking most of Georgia along the way. “He fought in the battles at Shiloh , Vicksburg , and Chattanooga with mixed results, but he is the only man to twice receive the thanks of Co...
Read more

1968 TET OFFENSIVE: The Beginning of the End for Continued U.S. Involvement in Vietnam

-
Image
  The Vietnam War after the Tet Offensive of 1968   The 1968 “Tet” Offensive spread out across South Vietnam between 30 and 31 January. The offensive produced shock both politically and militarily in the capital cities of Saigon and Washington D.C. The purpose of the offensive, in the extreme, was for Hanoi to cause a general uprising across the beleaguered cities of South Vietnam; a ‘popular enjoining’ of the fight by sympathetic South Vietnamese against the South Vietnamese government and her mighty ally, the United States. Sam Adams, a CIA analyst who was stationed in Vietnam at the time, believes Hanoi’s chief objective was to “jolt American public opinion right before the American elections. And in my view they succeeded in spades in doing that. [1] And at minimum, to cause chaos, sow worry and concern for South Vietnamese citizens and Americans alike, and to influence American public opinion. Surely the calculus of the North Vietnamese took into consideration the fre...
Read more

"CONVENTIONAL COMMANDERS IN AN UNCONVENTIONAL WAR: THE U.S. ARMY IN VIETNAM 1965-1967"

-
Image
INTRODUCTION                  Between 1965 and 1968 the majority of the Infantry Brigade and Battalion commanders fighting in Vietnam were veterans of the Second World War and/or the Korean war. Who were these   WWII veterans who led the U.S. Army in Vietnam and, as a group, how did they interpret their assigned tasks during the first two years of America’s involvement in Vietnam. This study illustrates how the ‘first wave’ of maneuver commanders, of whom a majority were veterans of the Second World War or Korea, adapted to myriad of conditions they faced across the 44 provinces in the Republic of Vietnam.   Within the historiography of the U.S. Army in Vietnam, the secondary literature concentrates on the strategy developed and implemented by the Military Assistance Command, Vietnam (MACV) and the ‘search and destroy’ operations executed across the country. A small group of scholars have argued that without any clear method th...
Read more